Pros and cons of online vs in-person therapy: Which one is right for you?


Navigating the world of therapy can be both exciting and overwhelming. With so many options available, finding the therapy modality that best suits your needs and preferences is paramount. Online therapy has seen a surge in the recent years since Covid-19, and it looks like it’s around to stay. So which one is better for you: online or in-person? 

There are advantages and drawbacks of each modality, and knowing them will empower you to make an educated decision based on your individual circumstances. In this article, we’ll consider factors such as convenience, accessibility, flexibility, human connection, comfort, and cost-effectiveness, among others.

Whether you’re seeking therapy for the first time or considering switching to a different modality, we’re here to provide you with the information and support you need. Our aim is to ensure that you embark on your therapy journey with confidence, knowing that you’re making the right choice for your mental health and well-being.

Pros of Online Therapy 

Feeling overwhelmed with the idea of attending therapy in-person? You’re not alone. The good news is that in today’s digital age, there’s a convenient and accessible alternative: online therapy. Online therapy, also known as teletherapy or virtual counseling, provides a unique set of benefits that can make seeking support easier and more comfortable for many individuals.

  1. Convenience: One of the most significant advantages of online therapy is its convenience. With just a few clicks, you can connect with a qualified therapist without leaving the comfort of your own home. You can schedule sessions at a time that works best for you, eliminating the need to commute or rearrange your daily routine. This flexibility can be a game-changer, especially for those with busy schedules or limited mobility.
  2. Accessibility: Online therapy breaks down barriers to mental healthcare by increasing accessibility. It enables individuals who may live in rural or remote areas to access therapy services that may not be readily available in their local communities. Additionally, for those with physical or mental health challenges that make leaving the house difficult, online therapy provides a lifeline of support that might otherwise be out of reach.
  3. Anonymity and Privacy: Some people feel more comfortable opening up about their struggles when they have a certain level of anonymity. Online therapy can provide a safe and confidential space for you to share your thoughts and emotions without the fear of being recognized by others in a waiting room or walking into a therapist’s office. This anonymity can help you feel more at ease and facilitate a deeper level of self-expression during sessions.
  4. Greater Options for Therapist Selection: Online therapy offers a wider pool of therapists to choose from, as you are not limited by geographical proximity. You have the opportunity to find a therapist who specializes in your specific concerns and has the expertise and experience to support your unique needs. This increased range of options ensures that you can find the right therapist for you, enhancing the likelihood of a strong and productive therapeutic relationship.
  5. Comfort Zone: For some individuals, the familiarity and comfort of their own surroundings can contribute to an enhanced therapeutic experience. Being in a familiar environment can help you feel more relaxed, enabling you to open up and engage in the therapeutic process more readily. Online therapy provides the opportunity to engage in self-reflection and growth within the comfort of your own personal space.

Remember, online therapy is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and it may not be suitable for everyone. However, it is essential to recognize that it offers several unique benefits that can make therapy more accessible, convenient, and comfortable for many individuals. Taking that first step towards seeking support for your mental health is commendable, no matter the modality you choose. Whether online or in-person, therapy can serve as a powerful tool on your journey towards living your brightest life.

Cons of Online Therapy 

While there are undeniable benefits to online therapy, it’s important to acknowledge that it may not be the best fit for everyone. Like any form of therapy, online therapy has its limitations and potential drawbacks. It’s essential to be aware of these cons so that you can make an informed decision when exploring your mental health support options.

  1. Technical Challenges: Online therapy relies on stable internet connections and functioning technology. Technical issues, such as poor video quality, audio disruptions, or connectivity problems, can disrupt the flow of a therapy session and hinder effective communication. While these issues can often be resolved, they can still be frustrating and may temporarily impact the quality of the therapeutic experience. Also, if you don’t have access to a stable internet connection, online therapy may not be an option for you. 
  2. Limited Non-Verbal Cues: In face-to-face therapy, non-verbal cues, such as body language and facial expressions, play a significant role in the communication between therapist and client. These cues can provide valuable insights that enrich the therapeutic process. However, in online therapy, some non-verbal cues may be less apparent due to the limitations of the screen. This may result in potential misinterpretations or a slightly different understanding of the client’s emotional state. If you do use online therapy, be sure to ask for video cameras to be on so you can read facial expressions to enhance the experience. 
  3. Distractions at Home: While online therapy allows you to receive support from the comfort of your own home, this environment can also present distractions that may interfere with your focus and engagement during sessions. Household noises, interruptions from family members, or the presence of personal belongings can sometimes make it challenging to create a dedicated and uninterrupted therapeutic space.
  4. Lack of Physical Presence: In traditional in-person therapy, the physical presence of the therapist can create a sense of trust, comfort, and connection. Some individuals find this comforting, as it provides a tangible source of support. While technology can bridge the gap to an extent, it’s essential to recognize that the absence of in-person interaction may affect the therapeutic alliance for some clients.
  5. Not Suitable for All Conditions: While online therapy can effectively address a wide range of mental health concerns, certain conditions may require a more hands-on, in-person approach. For instance, severe psychiatric conditions or crisis situations may be better served by immediate, in-person intervention. Additionally, some therapeutic modalities, such as bodywork or art therapy, may not translate as effectively to an online format.

Despite these potential challenges, online therapy continues to evolve and improve as a valuable mental health resource. It’s essential to weigh these considerations against the benefits and your personal circumstances before making a decision. Remember, therapy is a highly individualized experience, and what works best for one person may not be the optimal choice for another.

Pros of in-person therapy

In-person therapy has long been the traditional method of receiving mental health support, and for good reason. There are several unique advantages to face-to-face therapy that can greatly enhance the therapeutic experience. Let’s explore some of the pros of in-person therapy:

  1. Direct Connection and Human Presence: One of the most significant benefits of in-person therapy is the direct connection and human presence between you and your therapist. Being in the same physical space allows for a deeper sense of connection and rapport, promoting trust, understanding, and empathy. The ability to see your therapist’s expressions, body language, and gestures can deepen the therapeutic relationship and facilitate a more nuanced understanding of your emotions.
  2. Non-Verbal Cues and Communication: In-person therapy provides a rich environment for non-verbal cues, such as the subtle shifts in body language and facial expressions that can often convey unspoken thoughts and emotions. Your therapist can pick up on these cues and use them as valuable clues to better understand your experiences and tailor their approach accordingly. Having these additional layers of communication can enhance the therapeutic process and lead to more profound insights and breakthroughs.
  3. Immediate Support during Crisis Situations: In-person therapy can be particularly beneficial for individuals dealing with acute crisis situations or severe mental health conditions. The immediate presence of a trained therapist can provide a sense of safety and security during times of distress. While online therapy can offer support, in-person sessions can often provide the necessary reassurance and intervention with greater immediacy.
  4. Tangible Separation from Daily Life: Going to a physical therapy session can create a distinct separation between your therapeutic journey and your everyday life. Stepping into the therapist’s office can serve as a symbolic shift, signaling your commitment to focusing on your mental health. This physical separation can help create a dedicated space for exploring your thoughts, feelings, and challenges without the distractions of home or work.
  5. A Fully Present Therapist: In-person therapy allows your therapist to be fully present and undivided during sessions. Unlike online therapy, where technological glitches or connectivity issues may temporarily interrupt the flow of the session, in-person therapy ensures dedicated time and attention solely focused on your well-being. This undivided presence can foster a sense of safety, support, and validation, creating an optimal environment for healing and growth.

In-person therapy has a long-standing history of effectiveness and has been the preferred choice for many individuals seeking mental health support. The direct connection and human presence, along with the rich non-verbal communication, provide a unique therapeutic experience that resonates with many. However, it’s important to note that both online and in-person therapy have their merits, and the right choice will depend on your personal circumstances and preferences.

Cons of in-person therapy

While in-person therapy can be a meaningful and transformative experience, it’s important to note that it may not be the right fit for everyone. In addition to some of the inherent limitations of therapy in general, in-person therapy also has some specific drawbacks that can impact the therapeutic process. Here are some cons to consider when deciding whether in-person therapy is right for you:

  1. Geographical Limitations: One of the most significant drawbacks of in-person therapy is the geographical limitations it presents. As therapies are conducted face-to-face, you need to be physically present in the same location as the therapist, limiting your choices of therapists to those in your area. This can be especially limiting for individuals living in rural areas or those with mobility issues who may not have easy access to therapy.
  2. Higher Costs and Time Commitment: In-person therapy can be more expensive than online therapy as it typically involves additional costs such as transportation and office rental for the therapist. Additionally, in-person therapy requires more time commitment as you need to account for transportation, parking, waiting room, and the actual session time, making it more challenging to fit into a busy schedule.
  3. Less Flexibility: In-person therapy often requires a set schedule, making it less flexible than online therapy that can be more accommodating of your schedule. Additionally, unexpected life events, such as traffic or sudden illness, can disrupt the therapy session, leading to missed appointments and a less consistent therapy experience.
  4. Potential Discomfort: For some individuals, the thought of sharing their innermost thoughts and feelings in a face-to-face setting can be anxiety-provoking, leading to potential discomfort or self-consciousness. This discomfort can affect the degree of openness and vulnerability the individual feels, potentially hindering the therapeutic progress.
  5. Limited Choice of Therapists: Depending on your location and insurance coverage, you may have limited options when it comes to finding the right therapist for your needs and goals. This can be frustrating and lead to potential suboptimal therapy outcomes.

While in-person therapy has its drawbacks, it’s important to remember that it can also be highly effective for many individuals. Ultimately, the right choice of therapy modality will depend on your specific needs, preferences, and life circumstances. 

Which one is right for you?

Now that you know the benefits and drawbacks of both in-person and online therapy, which one is right for you? While you’re the only person who can answer that, here are some guidelines that can help you: 

Online therapy may be better if…

  • You live in a rural or small-town area where access to therapists is limited. 
  • You’re on a budget and want to find the most affordable option. 
  • You don’t have the time or means to drive to and from a therapy office.
  • You have social anxiety or other mental health issue that makes it difficult to meet face-to-face. 
  • You have children or pets that cannot be left alone for the duration of an in-person therapy session. 

In-person therapy may be better if… 

  • You have a psychiatric condition like schizophrenia, a personality disorder, or Bipolar. 
  • Face-to-face interaction is important to you. 
  • You want to have a neutral space (not your home) you can go and work through tough situations. 
  • There are people at home that you don’t want to overhear your therapy conversation, or you are unable to be in a private location while at home. 
  • You want to be able to separate your therapy sessions from the rest of your life and not bring it “home”. 

Choosing between online and in-person therapy can be a daunting decision, but it’s essential to prioritize your mental health and find the best therapy modality for your individual needs. Finding a therapy center that is committed to providing you with compassionate, informative, and empowering support every step of the way is vital. For example, companies such as Lifebulb, Brightline, or Grow Therapy are great online options. For local in-person therapists, check out Psychology Today for a list of therapists near you.

To Top

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This