Pallidan, an SEO and AEO agency for field service and home service businesses, has published a study of how AI assistants recommend local contractors.
The team asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews for the best plumbers, electricians, HVAC companies and roofers in the 20 largest US metros. Each answer was then compared with the Google Maps top 3 for the same city and trade.
The AI answers named 10.6% of the Maps top 3 businesses (66 of 624). 71.2% of the 208 answers named none of them.
What the data shows
ChatGPT named 12.1% of the Maps top 3, Google AI Overviews 10.4% and Gemini 9.2%.
HVAC was named least: 3.9% of its top 3 positions. Roofers were named most at 16.0%, then plumbers at 13.2% and electricians at 9.3%.
Reviews and names go together. Listings with 1,000 or more Google reviews were named 39.6% of the time. Listings with under 50 reviews were named 0.7% of the time.
Listings with no website were named in 0.4% of checks. Listings with a website were named in 9.9%.
45.7% of the 1,138 sources the AI tools cited were directories and ranking sites such as Yelp, Angi, Thumbtack and "best of" lists. Business websites made up 12.0%.
"Owners assume the Maps top 3 carries over into ChatGPT. In our data it mostly doesn't," said Sayeem Khan, founder of Pallidan. "The fix starts with a simple check. Ask the AI tools who the best in your trade and city are, then look at which sites they cite."
The data was collected on 30 and 31 October 2026. The study counts who gets named. It does not measure calls or jobs.
Read the full study, with method and tables: AI answers vs Google Maps, field service study 2026. The raw data is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 on GitHub.
About PallidanPallidan is an SEO and AEO agency for field service, home service and SaaS businesses in the US, Australia, the UK, Canada and New Zealand. It was founded in 2019 by Sayeem Khan.
Media Contact
Company: Pallidan
Name: Sayeem Khan
Email: [email protected]
Phone: +1 (719) 512-4553
